Fixer Upper Homes for Sale – Yeah, or No Way?

On June 19, 2008, Karin Elliott wrote -

Three years ago, when the market was hot here in the North Georgia community of Big Canoe, I sold a ton of listings with the key words “Fixer-Upper”. It seemed to be the phrase I like to refer to as the “Nobody’s Perfect” house, meaning though it’s not perfect, I can live with what I can’t change and fix the rest. Made sense for the market at the time.  Sellers with Big Canoe homes for sale were getting their prices and didn’t mind if their house wasn’t the “prettiest girl at the prom”. One classic example is a house I listed that was adorable from the outside, a perfect log cabin on an interior view lot. The plumbing was polybutylene and the aroma of cats and cigarettes resonated throughout the home. The owner was too busy to address any issues that needed attention. I worried about how the home would show and how it would reflect on the offers.

Listing day brought a few calls right off the bat. Within 3 weeks we had an offer. The owner wasn’t jazzed and countered heavily. The deal fell apart. No problem, enter “offer number 2″; buyer wanted a due diligence contract and the seller tried to shorten it to an “as-is” sale. It also fell through. Third time is a charm. I had a couple that found the home from the Smoke Signals (Big Canoe’s newspaper). Before I even met them I told them the house smelled like smoke and cats, but I’d be happy to show it to them if they still wanted to see it. They did, and just about bought it on the spot! It was my hottest listing!!

Today I am seeing the complete opposite of the aforementioned scenario. The Buyer’s market of today is looking for Big Canoe real estate that is in “tip-top” condition. Many are not interested in fixing anything or replacing carpet. What they want is a home in good shape with no foreseeable problems.  Sellers have the option of either fixing the problem areas or conceding to an additional price reduction. One way to prevent any surprises is for the sellers to look at your homes as if you were the buyers. Critique everything and fix it if you can.  Buyers, keep in mind that you may also have a home to sell and try to focus on the major issues. Minor issues are just weekend projects that can be easily resolved.

With all this said and done the negotiating should be a lot smoother and easier on everyone’s pocket!

One Response to “Fixer Upper Homes for Sale – Yeah, or No Way?”

  1. Dan Says:

    I’m married to you, so I’m entitled to give you a hard time – we just had a visitor on our site today that was looking for a “fixer upper north georgia mountains.” ;)

    I definitely agree that there’s not as much activity in the ‘fixer upper’ department as there was 2 years ago, but I think there’s always going to be a segment of real esate buyers that are specifically looking for fixer uppers.

Leave a Reply


Sign Up for North Georgia Real Estate Updates!

Receive Updates on New Listings, Big Canoe Community News, and North Georgia Real Estate Deals !

Your Email:
(Check your inbox for a confirmation email.)
Receive Updates Through Our RSS Feed
You can also receive updates by subscribing to our RSS Feed.

IBA Mountain Homes

Enter Search Terms:


IBA Mountain Homes is a realty group located in the North Georgia community of Big Canoe. Big Canoe® is a registered servicemark of Big Canoe, LLC. IBA Mountain Homes is not affiliated with the developer. IBA focuses on resales in Big Canoe including homes for sale, lots, and condos.


IBA created this blog to discuss living in Big Canoe as well as the North Georgia real estate market. We are full time residents of the Big Canoe community, and our job is real estate - thus the name of the blog! :) Our blog is opinion. Feel free to leave us a comment if you like, and as with anything on the internet, we urge you to always verify information independently.